Books

Is there a way to live without economic growth? 

David Pilling's Bending Adversity looks at Japan's lost decade and ageing population — the country's resilience may hold a key for the West

18 January 2014

9:00 AM

18 January 2014

9:00 AM

Bending Adversity: Japan and the Art of Survival David Pilling

Allen Lane, pp.385, £20, ISBN: 9781846145469

During Japan’s lost decade in the 1990s I found myself handing out rice balls to Tokyo’s homeless on the banks of the Sumida river. The former salary men — it was always men — slept in cardboard boxes the size of coffins. I peered into one. Its owner had neatly arranged his last few possessions. Crockery, two wash rags and a blanket were all emblazoned with the designer logos I associated with Japan’s boom years when I had lived in Tokyo. They had washed up like artefacts from another age in this unlikely setting. They signalled more than anything else to me that Japan’s economic miracle was well and truly in the past.

Financial Times Asia editor David Pilling lived in Japan for seven years. His latest book, Bending Adversity, does an excellent job of reappraising those lost years of economic deflation and social and political stagnation. His argument is simple. What happened to Japan is now coming to the West. After the collapse of Lehman Brothers and the subsequent global financial crisis, nearly every western government faces similar problems to Japan. We had better get used to living if not in a cardboard box then at least in a life without growth.

The book emphasises the resilience of the ordinary Japanese in comparison to a corrupt and arrogant political culture. ‘What Japan needs is a really good earthquake,’ advocated one senior official from the Ministry of Finance as an answer to Japan’s economic woes. Well he got his wish. The 2011 Tohoku earthquake and tsunami was so ‘good’ it shifted the earth on its axis and killed 19,000 people. Whether it has fixed Japan’s economic problems is open to question.

Pilling starts and ends with moving descriptions of the tsunami and its victims’ fortitude. From ground level the first thing most people saw of the tsunami was

a ghostly dust rising from buildings that were collapsing in the water’s path. The eerie white powder floated ahead of the wave like some terrible omen of death.


Later Pilling sees two women picking their way through a landscape of rubble. One holds up a sieve she had found, all that was left of the café they had owned, a small, familiar object in the midst of desolation, ‘It’s a bit pathetic, isn’t it?’ she says.

A cardboard home outside a theatre in Osaka, Japan Photo: AFP/Getty

A cardboard home outside a theatre in Osaka, Japan Photo: AFP/Getty

The inhabitants of the cardboard boxes on the Sumida river had been middle-class salary men. Japan experienced first what has now become an EU phenomenon. The impoverishment of the middle classes and the growth of inequality is the result of international trends, says Pilling — particularly the incorporation of hundreds of millions of Chinese workers into the global workforce after Beijing joined the World Trade Organisation in 2001.

They are one symptom of a bigger issue: how do we live in a declining economy? Economic growth is a myth to which we can no longer cling. Unless we expect the population of the world to keep growing indefinitely, ‘All economies will one day face the problems now confronting Japan.’ So how do we prosper, how do we offer our young the hope of a better future, asks Pilling, ‘without the impetus of ever-greater numbers’? Norihiro Karo, Professor of Japanese Literature at Waseda University, told the author: ‘Capitalism speaks in terms of limitless growth, but there are finite resources. What seemed possible in the 1960s and 1970s is clearly no long so.’

Japan is a stark example because its population is not merely stagnant but ‘on the verge of rapid decline’. In 1960 11 people of working age paid for every person over 60. By 2055 it will be 1.3 workers supporting every retired person.

So what can Japan teach us? Certainly, living in Tokyo during its boom years was a lesson to me that economic growth does not necessarily translate into a better quality of life. The majority of Japanese paid a harsh cost for their country’s success. We see something similar in London nowadays. The city is booming from record population growth. But as you are forced to stand on the train tomorrow, to search fruitlessly for a place at a nursery school or somewhere to live or rent, how happy or wealthy does that make you feel?

In Japan, as in the EU, it is the young who bear the brunt. Pilling explores their disillusionment as they struggle in poorly paid temporary work, are forced to live at home with their parents and marry late, if at all. They display a previously unheard of attitude in Japanese society: gambaranai — ‘don’t try too hard, don’t stress yourself’.

This is in contrast to the 82-year-old man Pilling found picking through the wreckage of his house after the tsunami. ‘Gambarimasu,’ he declared, ‘we must struggle on’. A year later he had rebuilt his house. There has to be a way, says Pilling, that we can live without growth. This fascinating and timely book shows us where to look for it.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

Available from the Spectator Bookshop, £16. Tel: 08430 600033

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10


Show comments
  • crosscop

    At least the people living in Japan will continue to be recognisably Japanese long after the population of England has ceased to be recognisably English. Unless the same madness grips them and they allow Japan to be colonised by the 3rd World, that is. But then can anyone really imagine that the Japanese ( or the Koreans or Chinese) would ever be so stupid as to allow themselves to become a minority in their own capital city? They must think that we are totally insane.

    • rick hamilton

      Agreed. They certainly wouldn’t stand by while their major manufacturing industries were sold off to foreign ownership for the sake of a quick buck for shareholders and early retirement for a few directors.

      Having been defeated in a world war and occupied by the victors they wouldn’t sign away their sovereignty to a bureacratic monster like the EU. And at the first sign of trouble from any immigrant it is a case of visa revoked, and out of the country on the next plane.

  • johnslattery

    I’m fed up with reading about this ‘lost decade’ lie. It simply never happened, it’s a media fabrication. You think Japan did not have downandouts living in cardboard boxes before 1990? Japan was and remains stable, rich, and dynamic. Growth slowed in the 2000s. Just as it did in Europe. That was all. There was no crisis, no jobless explosion, no wave of strikes, no currency collapse, no massive bankruptcies, none of the things that, say, Britain has experienced. All that happened was that Asia rose, closing the gap.

  • Bonkim

    Good analysis.

    Se need to prepare for a steady declining economy. With world populations exploding and resources depleting fast – the fast burn consumption led economy will soon falter.

    The world also has to find a smooth way to reduce population. Stop overseas aid so failed and failing societies will disappear or wake up and try to get strong and independent.

    At the rate of burn mankind’s tenure on earth – a century or two, could be decades. At least man now has a huge store of knowledge and analytical power – and should be able to devise means to survive with rapid population reduction.

  • visit japan, most evolved country in asia .. show me this freaking “lost decade” .. a media creation

    and “growth”? … what an immature concept!

    “growth” has nothing to do with transformation, evolution, refinement, quality of life … it is at best a lousy simulacrum

Close