What’s the point of BBC Music?

Plus: an odd but compelling start to David Byrne's new Sunday-afternoon show on 6 Music and a cleverly done Radio 2 drama about the 1965 meeting of Elvis and The Beatles

29 August 2015

9:00 AM

29 August 2015

9:00 AM

To Radio 2 to meet Bob Shennan, controller of the BBC’s most popular radio station (the station attracts one third of all listening hours) and now also head of the newish monolith that is BBC Music. Why corral all of the Corporation’s music output on radio and TV into one enormous sub-division (on a par with BBC News, BBC Drama and BBC Sport)? Isn’t this just another cost-cutting compromise, a way of saving money by smoothing out the BBC’s output (its first production was that weird mish-mash of God Only Knows by a constellation of stars)? How will specialist stations like Radio 3 and BBC4 survive if swallowed up in what is essentially a bureaucratic creative exercise, victims of corporate branding?

Shennan is, I suspect, a man you would not want to cross in an argument, but his passion for all things radio is mightily reassuring. He has, after all, masterminded the current Radio 2 surge to more than 15 million listeners, as well as ensuring not just the survival of 6 Music but also its astonishing audience increase to two million listeners (from 695,000 in 2010 when it was threatened with closure). His response to the current pro-phecies that there are bad times ahead for the BBC, given that the licence fee has to be renegotiated next year with a government that wants to present itself as a friend to taxpayers, is that it’s a bit of sabre-rattling but nothing really to worry about, provided that we as listeners stay loyal to the Corporation. Streamlining, making the same money go further, actually stimulates creativity.

As to the other threat from the rapid changes to the global market in music and broadcasting, from Amazon, Google, YouTube etc, with their multibillion funds and personalised playlists, Shennan has no doubt of the BBC’s superiority as a taste-maker. After all, he says, while his stations and Radio 1 make the hits, commercial radio merely plays them. Enough said.

Shennan, who was a founding creator of Radio 5 Live after learning his craft on commercial radio and sport, insists that what the BBC has that no amount of money can buy is the knowledge, experience and individuality of its presenters, and I would add its production values (plus that enormous archive). As David Byrne rather pompously claimed on his new Sunday afternoon show for 6 Music, ‘I am not an algorithm.’

Byrne doesn’t have the voice of Dylan; nor does he have Iggy Pop’s extraordinary ability to delve into the back story of where popular music came from. But he does have fascinating taste, and a musician’s authority. ‘My place,’ he told us on The David Byrne Radio Show, ‘is to make sure you hear something you like, and something that might surprise you, that you’ve never heard before, and things that don’t belong in the same category.’ This he did, taking us seamlessly from Curtis Mayfield (‘We the people who are darker than blue’) to the sound track of the film Planet of the Apes, followed by a version of the Goldfinger theme tune by the remarkable Petra Haden that sounded in places quite ape-like. Very odd, and quite compelling.

Another Shennan solution to shrinking budgets is to create seasons of programmes, and this weekend sees the start of a festival spurred by the anniversary of the meeting on 27 August 1965 of Elvis and the Beatles. Who would not wish to have been there, at the mansion in Bel Air where they all jammed for an afternoon? What did they talk about? Whose music did they play? Were John, Paul, George and Ringo intimidated? After all, he was the King and they were merely upstarts.

As Shennan explained, at last year’s big commissioning round in September several independent companies came up with ideas on how to mark the anniversary. He decided to splash his budget on one big drama, When Elvis Met the Beatles, written by Jeff Young (and produced by Eloise Whitmore and Dan Cocker), to be broadcast on Bank Holiday Monday. Very little is known about this seismic encounter in the history of popular music. It might have been a huge letdown, Elvis not taking much notice of the four lads from Liverpool and John, Paul, George and Ringo in turn being appalled to discover that their hero had feet of clay. Young’s drama hints at this and also at the potential rivalry between Brian Epstein, the Beatles’ manager, and Colonel Tom Parker, the ruthless operator who took over Elvis and controlled every aspect of his life.

The edginess is cleverly done, suggesting rather than stating quite what they all made of each other. Perhaps John did harp on about Elvis selling out by singing those dreadful songs on film? Maybe Ringo was the most sane, the most grown-up, the peacemaker? The music by Pete Storm as Elvis and members of the tribute band Imagine The Beatles did not have the resonance or kick of the originals but was an intriguing take on what might have been. This was tight writing and slick production, taking us beyond the encounter to what it might mean to be imprisoned by fame.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10

Show comments
  • grammarschoolman

    So no answer to the Radio 3 question and nothing about the effect on the Proms of becoming part of BBC Non-Music.

    Did he refuse to answer or did you neglect to ask?

  • Caractacus

    I listen to Minnesota Public Radio. In terms of music it makes the BBC look like Chas & Dave. On a much, much tinier budget.

    • Kohagen

      Just checked it out. Looks like a good model that we could use in the UK.

    • MacGuffin

      In the past two hours I have fallen in love with Minnesota Public Radio. Thank you.

    • John Standley

      Great tip, thanks.

    • King Zog

      Actually when I visited the US (Bethesda, Maryland) for the first time recently I was amazed to discover local radio and TV stations playing stuff that I would probably never hear or see in the UK. Knussen’s ‘Where The Wild Things Are’ on TV at 6.30pm. Extraordinary.

  • Callan

    “When Elvis met the Beatles”. I trust it is an improvement on the programme a couple of months ago “When Fats ( Waller) met Al ( Capone)”. Pathetic attempt to make a story out of nothing.

  • TheJustCity

    What’s the point of the BBC? With the gravy train now likely to continue to 2025, expect more BBC info-verts hubristically justifying themselves to the hateful little people who pay for it all.

  • JoeDM

    The dumbing-down of Radio 3 has been a national disgrace.

    • I need to% guide you to fantastic online freelancing opportunity… 3 to 5 h of work /a day… Weekly paycheck… Bonus opportunities…Payscale of $6k to $9k /month… Just several hrs of your free time, a pc, basic knowing of Internet and trusted internet-connection is what is required…Get more information by visiting my disqus^profile

    • Sten vs Bren

      Meh. Still less dumb than the competition.

    • King Zog

      I agree… somewhat. I mean, the core is still by far the great European musical tradition (or ‘Classical’ music, to use what is really only a marketing term). The real problem is the musical ignorance of the broader public. Most reasonably educated younger people (I’m 46, so to me that’s basically anyone under 35, I think) will unashamedly admit to an interest in the arts in general, but this seems in my experience to usually extend only to literature and the visual arts. When it comes to music it’s really only Popular Music (in the sense usually understood by that term) that’s acknowledged. Rarely will even Jazz get a look in. I mean, this is fine if it’s what people want (and I appreciate pop music myself, quite partial to a bit of Lady Gaga followed by a sampling of Cannibal Corpse), but I just think they’re missing out on so much joy and richness.

  • Pioneer

    What is the point of the BBC?

  • rtj1211

    What’s the point of The Spectator?

    • berosos_bubos

      To promote OsCam World state.

    • IainRMuir

      Doesn’t matter because you don’t have to pay for it.

  • mdj

    ‘ Shennan has no doubt of the BBC’s superiority as a taste-maker.’

    Did he explain – did you even ask – why he thought that was its mandate?