Australian letters

22 July 2017

9:00 AM

22 July 2017

9:00 AM

Stats 101

Sir: Jeremy Sammut’s discussion (July 15) of Tim Soutphommasane’s argument that “equality of opportunity is a myth in contemporary Australia” is interesting but both dialogues omit what should be an obvious point.

A business with, say, 1000 employees can certainly be “measured” according to the ethnic make-up of its workforce. However, the data will imply little because that process misses what should have been the first step: measuring the ethnic make-up of job applicants. If, for instance, no “Ethnicity X” are employed because none applied then that’s the reason none were hired – not because of discrimination.

A second step would take into account the ethnic breakdown of the locale – of the city, the region, the suburb or town; but certainly not of Australia. This is not to assume that “only locals” will apply but judging the hiring process of a business in Perth using the same “Australian” ethnic breakdown figures as for a business in Melbourne is banal.

If Tim Soutphommasane thinks that using data based on an Australia-wide ethnic breakdown is of any use in assessing business hiring practices in a widely diverse ethnic population spread, and without knowing who or how many initially applied for positions, he needs to enrol in Stats101 at the local evening college.
Robert Walker
Wagga Wagga, NSW

Left learners

Sir: Centre-right political parties and conservative institutions who endeavour to ingratiate themselves with the media by adopting left wing policies always seem to see their support collapse. Sweden, Canada, France under Chirac and Sarkozy, the UK and now Australia. The Catholic Church elected a left wing Pope in John XX111 in 1958 and he convened the Second Vatican Council to reform the Church to the acclaim of the Left. Church numbers have plummeted since. The Church of England has a take it or leave it approach to doctrine which seems to please the media and seen its numbers and relevance collapse.

How much reality do conservatives need before being motivated to stick with their principles?
David Hall
Springwood, NSW

Feminist bullies

Sir: Bettina Arndt is a passionate debunker misandrists and their agendas. As the mother and grandmother of males, I want to cheer her on for championing men’s rights and the rights of a St Paul’s College, a prestigious place of learning not to crumble under the pressure of a feminist agenda. It’s hard to believe that there are any companies or individuals left that have that sort of courage or the strength to resist. If St Paul’s College closes down it sends a strong message to anyone considering rebellion. I’m very much reminded of Star Trek’s Borg, a collective whose motto is ‘resistance is futile’ forcing capitulation and striking terror into the hearts of alien races before assimilating them. It is indeed time that the ‘powerful men…the esteemed members of St Paul’s alumni came together’ sent a message of their own and put a full stop to the bullying.
Mary Pearl
Melbourne, Victoria

Yes to Boris

Sir: Get Boris (15 July)! Get Boris to be prime minister, in fact. He is the only possible candidate for the Conservatives who has the flair, the experience, the ideas and the sense of humour to rescue the party and the country from its current malaise. That he has opposition there is no doubt — but then so did Winston Churchill when he was recalled by Lloyd George in 1917 to be minister of munitions, and again in 1940 when he became prime minister. To sideline him at this time would be foolish in the extreme and a further example of the party’s ineptitude.
George Burne
Woldingham, Surrey

Three-sided negotiation

Sir: Dr Krall’s ‘The view from Germany’ (15 July), records the sadness of Germans and other Europeans at the response of the European Union to the departure of the United Kingdom from the EU. The article highlights two important and related truths, which are seldom, if ever, appreciated.

The departure negotiations are, in reality, three-sided. On the one hand there is the future relationship between the UK and 27 other countries. The essential point for that relationship is that free trade in goods and services is mutually beneficial. If anyone doubts this proposition, it can be proved mathematically through the law of comparative advantage. On the other hand, there is a discussion about the EU as an organisation and what it secures from the departure negotiations. In this regard the interests of the EU are divergent from or in opposition to the interests of both the 27 other countries and the UK. In order to secure for itself benefits beyond any value that it gives to its member countries, the EU has to assign to itself a future importance and omnipotence in order to justify its demands. The UK negotiators would do well to remember that the true supplicant in the Brexit negotiations is not the UK but rather the EU, which wants a lot but gives nothing.
Timothy Straker
London WC1

Sectarian stitch-up

Sir: ‘Why does the Conservative party not field candidates in Ulster constituencies?’, asks John Nugee (Letters, 15 July). Something must have stopped him studying the Province’s electoral history over the last 25 years. Superseded by the Ulster Unionist party in 1886, official Tory candidates, approved by Conservative Central Office, reappeared at the 1992 general election. They stood in 11 of Northern Ireland’s (then) 17 seats, winning a total of 44,608 votes (including 14,371 in North Down where the Tory came second). Since then Conservative party HQ has pumped in money and advice, but to no avail. In June, Tory candidates standing in seven seats gained a mere 3,875 votes between them. Sinn Fein and the DUP have turned Ulster politics into an ugly sectarian duopoly.
Alistair Lexden
House of Lords, London SW1

A mixed race

Sir: Simon Barnes wonders if tennis player Johanna Konta is English (‘Game changers’, 15 July). It is a question answered more than 200 years ago by Daniel Defoe, who wrote in his poem ‘The True Born Englishman’ of our heterogenous populace that: ‘Fate jumbled them together, God knows how;/ What e’er they were they’re true-born English now…/…scarce one family is left alive,/ Which does not from some foreigner derive.’
Wynn Wheldon
London NW6

English rugby

Sir: Simon Barnes was pulling his punches when discussing English rugby players who are not actually English (Game changers, 15 July). While all international rugby teams are guilty of adding foreign-born players to their ranks under residency rules — which World Rugby is thankfully changing — the RFU is easily one of the worst offenders.

Billy Vunipola was mentioned, but what of his brother Mako (born in New Zealand)? Other ‘English’ players include: Ben Te’o and Denny Solomona (both New Zealand), Nathan Hughes (Fiji), Marland Yarde (St Lucia) and Manu Tuilagi (Samoa). Even the England captain, Dylan Hartley, isn’t English, having been born and raised in New Zealand. Ironically, Maro Itoje (who has Nigerian parents), and who was singled out by Mr Barnes in his piece, is one of the most English players in the team, having been born in England!
Evan Byrne
London SW9

Smoke damage

Sir: With respect, Mr Willis is not looking beyond the tip of his irritated nose when he complains about cigarette smoke (Letters, 15 July). I don’t care for cigarette smoke either, but the smoking ban has destroyed the rural public house, once a cultural asset and now an endangered species. Drive through the home counties of London and mourn the derelict pubs, their once-smart signs hanging forlorn.
Nick Dawson
London W12

Get involved, Melissa

Sir: Melissa Kite is obviously right to be cross about not being allowed to ride her horse in her village, and her point about excessive signage is well-made (Real Life, 15 July). But the subsequent rant against her parish councillors is slightly bonkers, particularly when she seems to support defacing signs and the smashing of car windows.

My experience as a parish councillor is that there are many who stand on the sidelines, moaning about this and that, and remarkably few who actually try to do something for their village. Maybe it’s time for Melissa to lend a hand.
Terence Blacker
Diss, Norfolk

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10

Show comments