What the NHS owes the Tories

Jeremy Hunt's focus on 'never events' is in the tradition of Nye Bevan

25 January 2014

9:00 AM

25 January 2014

9:00 AM

Pinned to the wall of Jeremy Hunt’s office in the Department of Health is an A1 piece of paper detailing that week’s ‘Never Events’. It catalogues the mistakes that have been made in NHS hospitals that should never have happened: people having the wrong leg amputated, swabs being left inside patients after surgery and the like. This grim list is a rebuke to the glib, Danny Boyle-style rhetoric which dominates all political debate about the NHS and treats any attempt to examine the failings of British health care as heresy.

One can’t imagine Andy Burnham, the last Labour health secretary and the shadow secretary of state, approving of Hunt’s decision to display this information so prominently. Earlier this month he accused the Health Secretary of being on a ‘mission to run down the health service’ so that it can be privatised. But Hunt’s decision to have this list up in his office would have been applauded by one of the NHS’s founders, Aneurin Bevan. Given that he wanted the clang of a dropped bedpan to reverberate in Whitehall, Bevan would surely have approved of the Health Secretary’s knowing of the worst mistakes made by the service.

Hunt is about as different personally and politically from Bevan as it is possible to be: he is the son of an admiral, not a coal miner, and a Thatcherite, not a socialist. He does, however, share Bevan’s desire to know what is happening inside every NHS hospital. He begins his day by reading, and replying to, a patient who has written to him about the care that they have received from the NHS.

These letters are behind Hunt’s latest proposal: he wants every patient in hospital to have a named doctor looking after them for their whole stay. His aim is a board above each bed with the name of the doctor who is responsible for this patient for as long as they are in hospital. He believes that this would improve the quality of care by ensuring continuity. It would provide a point of contact for the patient and their family and prevent people from being passed from pillar to post inside hospital. These doctors would then discharge you into the care of a named GP.

This idea is hardly a complicated one. But it is precisely the kind of thing that had fallen by the wayside in an increasingly targets-obsessed NHS where, as the Francis report into what happened at Mid-Staffs revealed, compassion can be lacking. But it will require Hunt to find a way round the European Union’s working time directive which, with its 48-hour working week, would not allow doctors to be responsible for a patient at all times.

The proposal is emblematic of Hunt’s approach as Health Secretary. After the acronym-heavy structural reforms of Andrew Lansley’s tenure, Hunt favours patient-friendly interventions that can be explained in plain English.

Funnily enough, the best way to measure Hunt’s political success is by how far down the political order of battle the NHS is. The Tory leadership reluctantly accepts that it can never win a war with Labour over the health service and that its best hope is to neutralise the issue. If health doesn’t figure prominently in the next election campaign, that will be a boon for the Tories. It was notable that in Cameron’s New Year article setting out his long-term economic plan, health and the NHS were not mentioned.

This is a change from the early years of Cameron’s leadership, when he declared that his priorities could be summed up in three letters: ‘N, H, S.’ Cameron used his commitment to the NHS to prove that he was a different kind of Tory.

But this softly-softly approach, while politically effective — health hardly featured in the 2010 general election campaign — was undermined by the huge reorganisation that Andrew Lansley commissioned on becoming Health Secretary. His reforms had intellectual merit, but they jarred with Cameron’s talk in opposition of no more top-down reorganisations. The problem was compounded by the failure to explain to patients why the changes were needed, or how they would benefit them.

Hunt, by contrast, has tried to talk about everything in terms of patient interest. He is also doing an effective job in reducing the political salience of the issue: there have been half a dozen Prime Minister’s Questions since Miliband last asked Cameron about the health service. Labour, however, still has a commanding 11-point leadon the issue.

But the most important thing that Hunt is doing is bringing glasnost to the NHS. As the Francis report showed, for far too long poor care inside the health service was covered up or ignored. Hunt’s answer to this has been to embrace transparency. He’s introduced a new inspection regime which has already seen almost 10 per cent of hospitals placed in special measures.

These inspection reports should allow a proper discussion about why some hospitals are so much worse than others, a subject that is too often avoided. For a supposedly national service, the variance in quality inside the NHS is shocking. Hunt is trying to address this by making hospitals take more responsibility for their own actions. He has changed the rules so that if in negligence cases they do not admit fault at the earliest opportunity then the hospital itself, not the central NHS, has to pay compensation.

There is more that could be done to support transparency. Charlotte Leslie, who won this magazine’s backbencher of the year award for campaigning for accountability over the Mid-Staffs scandal, thinks that whistleblowers need to be given far more protection. She argues that if they have their claims upheld, they should be offered special assistance when applying for other jobs inside the NHS. Without this, she fears, they risk being penalised for speaking up.

As part of the Tories’ attempt to prevent health becoming an election issue, they are almost certain to commit again to ring-fencing the NHS budget. This promise will be the Tory response when Labour claim they can’t be trusted with the NHS. But the far more important Tory achievement will be to have brought greater transparency to Britain’s health service.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10

Show comments
  • mikey_w3

    48 hour week limit is a red herring. It would perfectly possible to be responsible without being ‘clocked on’ or physically present. All that would be required is to hand over to someone who is is on duty (& to have the courtesy to let the patient know)!

    • Terry Field

      48 hours!
      Who needs 48 hours?!?
      It is really quite possible to attack and damage patients in much less time if sufficient management resource is applied.
      I would have thought that would be obvious.

  • Mr Creosote

    An acquaintance was recently on a hospital ward, lying in pain and generally suffering. Having rung the bell for over an hour to alert the nurse, he eventually gave up, rang the hospital on his mobile and asked the receptionist to ring the ward and ask a member of staff to help him.

    • Terry Field

      He has undermined the NHS
      He should be ashamed of himself.
      Tory quisling!

  • Sminky

    Shocking as these ‘never events’ are, they happen in every health system in the world. There is no evidence that they happen any more or less in the NHS than in other health systems. Indeed, there is good evidence that the uniform nature of the NHS has led to more rapid adoption of those interventions that reduce harm, e.g. the WHO Safer Surgery Checklist.
    The NHS will improve when power is devolved to individual hospitals and they become civic institutions in the communities they serve. The idea that you can improve the safety of care by Ministerial diktat is grotesque and just another version of New Labour centralism.
    Conservatives should be against running hospitals from Whitehall, even if it is a conservative doing it and there is some clear, short-term political advantage. Gove’s actions in education show that he really believes this: Hunt’s actions in health show him to be a shallow opportunist.

  • tribalterror

    Lets hope Gove has the same success with education – the other bastion of self serving opacity. Eliminating grade inflation was a good start…but as with the NHS vested interests with the usual support of the BBC will fight back viciously…

    • Terry Field

      No Tory government would have the Balls to smash the BBC and redistribute the licence fee to the best commercial stations as well as a rump beeb.
      It is safe to spread propaganda.

  • Terry Field

    The NHS is the Soviet Union in Britain. It’s apologists suffer from Stockholm Syndrome.
    Glad I left.
    Bollie anyone?!?

  • drydamol1


    Genetically Modified Crops we were told was the Saviour
    of Starvation in African Countries. Corporate Greed having taken over have left
    farmers in Debt with no crops and no hope .The Suicide count has never been
    greater among them .The seeds are made so as not to re-grow leaving farmers
    with a failed crops and owing the Corporations .

    The UK will undertake the Planting of GM crops this
    Spring that will yield Fish Oil – why not Politics are Artificial and we are
    made to swallow them .

    The overpriced
    substandard food on sale today contains less nutrients and vitamins than home
    grown produce but the EU pays Farmers not to grow certain Produce in favour
    of Rigged Market Produce .

    We are warned about Salt & Sugar levels ,to eat five
    a day of Vegetables or Fruit ,cut down on fatty foods and to fulfil their
    obligation the Government introduced a programme of indirectly informing us of the
    risk of high Cholesterol and Blood Pressure
    .Whenever we go to our Doctors for
    whatever reason four main points are mentioned Alcohol ,Smoking
    Cholesterol and Blood Pressure .Anyone receiving Benefits is expected to eat a
    Healthy Diet on a pittance and be fit for Workfare – Remind you of somewhere .


  • Laura Zamora

    !!! How Dr.Ukaka Save My Broken Heart Of Marriage Today !!!

    Glorious be unto Dr. Ukaka the great man and ever, my name is Sarah from Taxes city usa. since 1 and a half year I have witness what is called heart broken. my boyfriend that promised me marriage failed me and impregnate me and leave,he dump me,he stop calling” he stop picking my calls,and he no longer respond to me. I have be looking for solution,I fall into the hands of fake spell caster,they rough me off and took my money without help.I have cried,I have weep”and tears runs out of eyes. The silentness in my heart brought me to the deepest path of failure that I lost my job. Crying all day,because of my life was lonely. So thanks to Ukaka that came into my life and brought me the greatest joy that was lost. I saw his mail while browsing and I contact and tell him what I am passing through with no doubt because what saw about him,was enough to believe. And I was given words of solution on what to do. I can’t really help thinking about it I have tried to see what I can do, I manage to provide him some materials and he help me with the rest,after casting the spell, 12hrs later he came with rose on his hand and I was even about going out,i saw him in front of my door when he sees me he knee and said he is dying I should forgive him and accept him back he was crying,I can’t wait to let him finish I quickly crab him and kiss him, just then” he said he is restless without me, just as the prophet has said he will be. He brought out a ring and put it on my hand. Our wedding day was scheduled,1week after we got married. today makes it 2weeks and we are living happily I don’t know how to praise him enough, he has done me a thing I can never forget. And I can’t really share to myself alone, I want y’all to help me praise him because if it is wasn’t for him I already plan of committing suicide. But right now I am now so happy more than I was before. And you out there crying for help you’ve already got one,Ukaka is the man that you need in all rampart. contact his address if you need his service, freedomlovespell@hotmail.com also contact him on his web site: freedomlovespelltemple.yolasite.com