Mind your language

Mind your language: Box set

It’s not going to be replaced with the boxed set, so you might as well stop seething

23 January 2016

9:00 AM

23 January 2016

9:00 AM

There is no chance whatsoever of box set being replaced by the more correct form boxed set. So stop seething about it and causing yourself distress.

The form, boxed set has been in use for 125 years or so, but the Oxford English Dictionary has dug up a reference from Wisconsin in 1969 to a ‘box set of tumblers’. Admittedly, binge-watching a set of tumblers for hours on end would be a minority interest.

The triumph of box set is partly a matter of phonetics. In ordinary speech the d after the s sound in boxed set is hardly out before the poor old tongue gets round to hissing the initial letter of set.

There is an analogy here with sixth. I have heard people complain of news-readers or actors on television mispronouncing sixth. The tendency is to say sicth. We may all swear that we say sixth, but recordings suggest otherwise. It has never been a word to be pronounced phonetically. The Elizabethans were not too hot on the th sound. In the First Folio of Shakespeare, for example, the names of three history plays are spelt Henry the Sixt. So it seems to be a choice between the x and the th. You can’t have both.

The opposite tendency is to be seen in terraced houses. That seems to me the prevalent form. Keen pedants insist that it implies they are terraced like the Hanging Gardens of Babylon. To be sure, Jane Austen wrote of a ‘Terrace House’ and James Joyce wrote it as one word. An interesting anomaly, which the OED caught up with in 2007, has been to use terrace to mean just one house in the terrace. It found a reference in 1894 to the ambitious man ‘hurrying to get rich and own his little terrace’.

I have even heard domestic grammarians insisting it is an error to write of a bomb site; it should be bombed site. No example of bombed site is to be found in the 20 volumes of the OED (now grangerised by bulky online interpolations). So we should peacefully sit in our terraced houses next to a bomb site gorging on box sets without fear of censure.

Got something to add? Join the discussion and comment below.

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it. Try your first 10 weeks for just $10

Show comments
  • Charles Wells

    In the USA many people call a satellite dish a “satellite”.

  • King Kibbutz

    Why aren’t videos, videoes?

  • Similarly, we now have ‘screen porches’ instead of ‘screened porches’ and ‘finish floor’ or ‘finish garage’ instead of ‘finished’.

    Then there’s “Temperature” and “Literature”– The same people who save a syllable by saying “litature” and “tempature” always seem to say “methodology” when they actually mean “method”…. a tad pretentious?

    And ‘yeah’ vs ‘yea’ FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS GOOD AND HOLY the word ‘yea’ is pronounced as ‘yay’ which I’ve noticed is now being spelled ‘yey’ to distinguish it. I know; these are lost causes.

    • Copyright101

      We must fight on!

  • Yorkshiremerlin

    In exactly the same way as people refer to items as “Bog standard” instead of correctly “Box Standard” i.e unmodified/as manufactured

  • Hamburger

    I always assumed that a box set was a set in a box, even if it was boxed. As far as bomb site, it does assume that any unexploded bombs which may be there have not been cleared, which still is often the case here.